What’s the Best Yarn for Tapestry Crochet?

Have you ever made a tapestry crochet blanket and been a bit disappointed with the final result? Perhaps you’ve not liked the feel of it, its thickness, or how the stitches or colorwork pattern look. Or maybe you’ve just not really enjoyed the process of making it.

If you’ve experienced any of these things, you’re certainly not alone. Also, there’s a good chance that the reason for these issues is simply down to the wrong choice of yarn.

Choosing the right yarn for a tapestry crochet blanket is incredibly important. The yarn you select will affect not only the look and feel of the finished item but also how enjoyable the process of creating is.

In this post, we’ll consider how you can choose the best yarn for your tapestry crochet projects so that you can create items with the confidence that you will love the end result. We’ll look at blankets, garments and wearable accessories, bags, and home décor items, and what yarns are best for each of these different types of products. We’ll consider yarn thickness, fiber content and colors.

You can read on to learn about all of this or, if you prefer, you can watch me discussing this topic in detail in this video.

As always, if you have any questions or comments, please feel free to leave a comment below.

What is Tapestry Crochet?

Tapestry crochet is a colour work technique that allows you to create beautiful patterns with two or more different coloured yarns. You can do tapestry crochet with any of the basic crochet stitches, from single crochet right up to double or treble crochet. In tapestry crochet, each stitch is made with a particular yarn and you carry along any unused yarn(s) by crocheting over it until needed.

Tapestry Crochet Blankets

I adore making tapestry crochet blankets because the range of patterns you can create is simply limitless. It’s absolutely addictive creating a colour work pattern and watching it grow as you add more motifs or rows to your blanket.

When choosing a yarn for a tapestry crochet blanket, think about what kind of drape you would like. Tapestry crochet works best if the stitches are relatively tight so that the carried yarn is well covered. Also, as there is carried yarn, this increases the overall thickness of the blanket slightly, compared to techniques where there is no carried yarn. These factors mean that if you would like a lot of drape, then going for a DK or even thinner yarn would be a good choice.

On the other hand, if you’re happy to have a slightly thicker (and maybe cosier) blanket, then an aran yarn can also work really well. Aran, for example, could be a great option if you’re making a picnic blanket or bedspread.

When it comes to the fibre content of your yarn, if warmth is an important factor for you then selecting a yarn with some animal fibres (e.g. wool) will certainly increase the cosiness. Acrylic is another good choice for warmth and is a great option cost-wise, especially if you’re making a large blanket.

However, acrylic and wool-based yarns do have a certain fuzziness to them. This is not necessarily a bad thing by any means and can look absolutely great. Nevertheless, if you prefer a slightly “crisper” look to your blanket, with clearer stitch definition, then choosing a cotton yarn might be the way to go. Cotton yarns can still be really soft but without the halo you get around acrylic and wool based yarns. This means that the colour work pattern you create with cotton yarn can really stand out. You can even get some yarns which are a blend of cotton and acrylic, which is a great compromise between the two.

Tapestry Crochet Garments and Accessories

When it comes to garments and accessories, like sweaters, cardigans, hats, shawls and scarfs, the yarn weight is usually clearly specified in the pattern. However, if you’re designing your own tapestry crochet garment, then I would recommend using a 4 ply or even thinner yarn. Using relatively thin yarns means that the resulting fabric will have a good drape and won’t be too thick or stiff. It also allows you to create more intricate colorwork patterns as you’ll have more stitches to play with in a given area.

For winter accessories like cozy hats of scarves, thicker yarns like DK or aran weight could be used.

In terms of fibre content, animal fibres are a great choice if warmth is an important factor. Yarns with animal fibres make wonderfully cosy, and perhaps slightly fuzzy, garments and accessories.

However, if you’re making an item for the summer months, then using a cotton or linen yarn would probably be best. Cotton and linen are great choices when you don’t want your item to be too hot! They also give great stitch definition to your colorwork.

Tapestry Crochet Bags

With crochet bags, one of the most important factors to consider is that it doesn’t stretch. As such, it’s best to choose a non-stretchy yarn for your project.

You also want a yarn that won’t catch too much on any items you may put in your bag.

Finally, you most likely want a yarn that can be used to create tight stitches without significant gaps.

All of these points mean that cotton yarn is a great choice for tapestry crochet bags. As mentioned above, it also gives really great stitch definition.

In terms of weight, I like to make my bags with DK or aran weight cotton. I find this gives just the right thickness to the final bag. However, if you were making a smaller or more decorative item then you could try a 4ply yarn.

Tapestry Crochet Home Décor

The yarn you choose for a home décor item can vary quite a bit depending on the item.

For cushions, you could choose a fuzzy or non-fuzzy yarn. However, if a cushion is to be used quite a bit I’d recommend a relatively hard-wearing yarn like cotton. The weight you use is up to you really. It will depend on how intricate a colour work pattern you’d like to create.

For table mats and runners, go for thicker yarns like aran. If you might be placing hot dishes on them, definitely opt for cotton rather than a synthetic fibre that might melt.

Watch the Full Video Guide Here

Curious to find out more? Watch my full video guide here.

Feeling Inspired to Try Some Tapestry Crochet?

If you’d like more practical guidance before you start, my step-by-step guide to tapestry crochet covers the core technique in full. And once you’ve settled on your yarn type, my post on which hook size is best for tapestry crochet will help you choose the right hook to go with it. If you’d like specific yarn recommendations rather than general guidance, I’ve also put together a list of my top ten yarns for tapestry crochet – all yarns I’ve used in my own projects.

For a full collection of tapestry crochet tutorials, visit the Tapestry Crochet Hub.

More Crochet Tips and Advice – Plus Two FREE Patterns

Sign up to my email list to receive a monthly newsletter with crochet news, tips and advice, as well as details of new pattern releases and exclusive discounts. Plus, receive TWO FREE PATTERNS when you sign up here today.