What Came First: Knitting or Crochet?

When exploring the world of handcrafted textiles, the age-old debate often arises: what came first, knitting or crochet? This question has piqued the curiosity of many enthusiasts and historians alike, leading to a fascinating exploration of the origins of these well-loved crafts.

Knitting, with its two-needle technique, and crochet, characterized by its single hook, may seem similar on the surface, but their histories differ markedly.

By examining the artifacts, techniques, and cultural influences of both knitting and crochet, we’re able to piece together a captivating narrative of their respective origins. Although we may not be able to definitively answer which came first, this exploration provides us with a deeper understanding and appreciation for these cherished forms of textile art.

Historical Background

The history of knitting and crochet is an intriguing adventure that intertwines different eras and cultures. To understand their roots, let’s take a closer look at the origins of knitting and crochet.

Knitting Origins

Knitting is an ancient craft believed to have originated in Egypt or the Middle East. Fragments of knitted items have been discovered dating back as far as the 11th century.

• Spread through Europe: Knitting gradually spread through Europe, finding its way into the hands of artisans who developed their unique techniques and styles.
• Guilds and Trade: Exclusive knitting guilds emerged in the 13th and 14th centuries, contributing to the craft’s growth and popularity. Guild membership was considered prestigious, and members would undergo years of apprenticeship before becoming masters.
• Industrial Revolution: The development of knitting machines in the 16th century spurred a rapid expansion of the knitting industry, leading to the mass production of knitted fabrics during the industrial revolution.

Crochet Origins

While knitting boasts a long and well-documented history, the origin of crochet is less certain, with several competing theories.

• Ancient Roots: Some experts believe crochet can be traced back to ancient civilizations like the Incas, Native Americans, or even ancient China. However, this is still debated among scholars.
• 16th Century Europe: Others suggest that crochet emerged in 16th century Europe, growing alongside knitting as a result of cultural exchanges and evolving needlework techniques.
• 19th Century Renewal: Regardless of its murky beginnings, crochet experienced a resurgence in the 19th century. During this time, crocheted lace patterns and articles became popular across Europe and America.

Both knitting and crochet share a common thread of being adaptable, practical, and artistic crafts. Throughout history, these skills have brought warmth and style to both the wearers and creators of various knitted and crocheted items.

Evolution of Techniques

Early Knitting

Knitting can be traced back to ancient times, with the earliest examples found in Egypt. These include socks, which are believed to have been created around the 3rd century CE. Notably, the technique involved the use of several needles:

• Double-pointed needles, made of materials like bone or metal
• Circular needles, for creating seamless tubes
• Straight needles, for creating flat pieces

As trade increased throughout the Middle Ages, knitting techniques spread to Europe. This resulted in a variety of regional patterns and styles. Some examples include:

• The Celtic cable, a complex intertwining found primarily in Irish knitting
• Fair Isle, a Scottish pattern featuring multiple colors
• Aran knitting, characterized by distinctive textures and stitches

Early Crochet

The history of crochet is less clear than knitting. However, there is evidence to suggest that it was practiced in several ancient civilizations. Due to its simple tools and techniques, crochet gained popularity for various applications:

• Sailing and fishing, for creating nets and rope
• Agriculture, for making soft containers
• Household items, such as doilies and lace trimmings

Unlike knitting, which often utilized multiple needles, crochet requires only a single hook. The vast array of available shapes and structures made it suitable for:

1. Three-dimensional work, like baskets and toys
2. Two-dimensional work, such as lace and scarves
3. Organic shapes, like flowers and leaves

In the 19th century, crochet became widely popular thanks to pattern books and emerging technology. Examples of popular crochet patterns of the era include:

• Granny square, a beginner-friendly design often used for blankets
• Filet crochet, which creates open, airy designs
• Irish crochet, known for its intricate designs and elaborate motifs

Similarities and Differences

Materials and Tools

Both knitting and crochet utilize yarn or thread to create fabric. They share a variety of materials, like wool, cotton, and acrylic. However, the tools they use differ significantly:

• Knitting requires two needles, which can be straight or circular (joined by a cable).
• Crochet relies on a single hook, available in various sizes and materials.

Stitches and Patterns

Knitting and crochet techniques have unique stitches, producing distinct textures and patterns. Some similarities and differences include:

• Both use basic stitches like single (crochet) and knit (knitting) as building blocks.
• Advanced stitches create intricate patterns, with knitting relying on combinations of knit and purl, while crochet employs a range of techniques like increases, decreases, and clusters.
• Crochet patterns often have a more three-dimensional appearance, whereas knitting typically results in flat or textured surfaces.

In conclusion, while knitting and crochet share some similarities in materials, their tools and techniques differ, offering unique creative possibilities.

Impact on Cultures

The history and evolution of knitting and crochet have not only been about the development of the techniques but also about their impact on various societies and cultures. In this section, we’ll discuss the role of knitting and crochet in society, and explore their influence on different communities.

Knitting in Society

Knitting has been a significant part of many cultures across the world. Its influence can be seen in various aspects of society, such as:

• Folklore and tradition: The intricate patterns and designs found in traditional knitwear are often deeply rooted in local folklore and symbolism.
• Fashion: Throughout history, knitting has been a popular choice for functional, as well as fashionable garments, from hand-knitted hats to intricate sweaters still in demand today.
• Employment and cottage industry: During the Industrial Revolution, knitting was an important source of supplementary income for families in Europe, especially in areas with a strong tradition of skilled hand-knitting.
• Social significance: Knitting often held social significance as well, acting as a means to bring people together in knitting circles or simply spending quality time.

Crochet in Society

Likewise, crochet has also had cultural, social, and economic effects on communities around the world:

• The Arts: Historically, crochet has been a medium for exquisite lacework, contributing to its strong presence in the decorative arts and home décor.
• Fashion and design: Just like knitting, crochet has also made its mark on the world of fashion, providing unique texture and patterns to clothing, accessories, and footwear.
• Empowerment and independence: At times, crochet has played a crucial role in empowering women by providing them with a profitable skill, fostering financial independence and self-sufficiency.
• Community and self-expression: Crochet has been a way for people to express their individuality, creativity, and connection to their cultural heritage, while also nurturing bonds within their communities.

Both knitting and crochet have made their mark on history and culture in unique and important ways. These crafts have transcended mere practicality and are woven into the fabric of societies worldwide, representing stories, histories, and self-expression.

What Came First: Knitting or Crochet? – Conclusion

In the quest to determine whether knitting or crochet came first, it’s important to consider the historical evidence available. While both crafts share similarities and have evolved over time, they each have their own distinct origins.

Knitting can be traced back to Ancient Egypt, where the earliest known examples were found in the form of socks. With records dating as early as the 11th century, knitting was later refined and spread throughout Europe.

On the other hand, crochet’s origins are harder to pinpoint. Some evidence suggests that crochet developed as a unique pastime during the 19th century, while others believe it evolved from earlier forms of textile art. The earliest examples of crochet were found in 19th-century Europe and America.

In conclusion, it is likely that knitting predates crochet, based on the available historical evidence. However, both crafts have rich histories and continue to be popular worldwide, serving as creative outlets for countless individuals.

It is important to appreciate the different techniques and skills involved in each craft and recognize that knitting and crochet stand as unique art forms in their own right. Throughout history, they have shaped the world of textiles, art, and fashion, leaving a lasting impact that continues to inspire generations to come.

More Crochet Tips and Advice – Plus Two FREE Patterns

Sign up to my email list to receive a monthly newsletter with crochet news, tips and advice, as well as details of new pattern releases and exclusive discounts. Plus, receive TWO FREE PATTERNS when you sign up today.